12/01/2007
When do Words Become Terms?
The SJC report against Wilkins reads:
"In the examination, TE Wilkins redefined biblical and Confessional terms before giving his assent to the teachings of Scripture and The Westminster Standards. TE Wilkins maintains that the Bible and The Westminster Standards teach differing doctrines."
This claim raises several questions:
1. What is the difference between a "term" and a "word"?
Generally, I'd say that a "term" is a word or phrase that has been applied to a specific act of signification in a specific context either for so long that it takes on this technical meaning to all of those familiar with the context or as a result of stipulation.
2. Does the bible contain "terms"?
Probably so. We can, for instance, detect a technical use of vocabulary for the sacrificial system in Paul. He might pick up on the vocabulary of the Septuagint, for instance, and use a word that would connote certain Levitical sacrifices to a well-prepared reader aware of the context. John uses the word "logos" and this has caused all manner of disputes between those who view this term to be derived from Greek philosophy and those who see a reference to certain Hebrew ideas. (I'm not falling into the fallacy of a 'greek mind' vs. a 'hebrew mind' here or anything, I'm just pointing out that when using technical vocabulary in a certain way (using a term), that the context matters - especially the ethno-linguistic context.)
This is a problematic notion. The Bible may "use" terms, but does it define them? The Bible consists of letters, explanations, stories, poems, etc. It does not go into the mode of "definition." Most of the "is" statements in the Bible are nothing like "A 'bachelor' is an unmarried male." They are more like - "Love is kind, it does not falter." And they certainly are nothing like "Justification is an act of God's free grace whereby he....". And they *certainly certainly* are not like those times when Klineans say things like "grace is a word only used in a context of human demerit." That's what we use the technical term "bullshit" for in the trade.
4. If it does not, how do we extract the "definition" of a term in order to have something to compare to Wilkins's "definition"?
And so this is the question. What biblical "terms" has Wilkins reinterpreted? "Justification" - well, is that a "term"? If so, then Paul and James need to get together on this one. Is it "baptism" - if so, then hand washing suddenly becomes a holy rite (or the sacrament of baptism becomes as common as handwashing). See the difficulty? In order for the SJC to allege, much less prove, that Wilkins "redefines biblical terms" they would have to list the terms in question, provide their summary of the bible's "definition" of these terms, and then provide an argument that the term in question a. is a 'term', and b. means what they have alleged. Finally, they have to tell when the word or phrase that constitutes their "term" is used in non-technical senses (i.e., as a word, not a term.)
Linguists will note that all words are terms in some sense - signification is a practical matter; when we hand a child a nerf basketball and say "BALL!" we've stipulated that B-A-L-L refers to the shape and not the color of the ball we've just handed the child, but it could just have easily been our word for orange. And yet the work of signification done by terms is different than the work of signification done by words in non-technical discourse. Because even if two thermal physicists were talking, they could still refer to a female co-worker as "hot" regardless of her temperature.
There are other curious things about this charge. Does the bible contain "doctrines" in the same sense we use the word "doctrine" to reply to the definitions contained in the Westminster standards? Can we blame a pastor for believing more than is comprehended in the standards if that pastoral extra is not in conflict with the standards or with the bible? How does the SJC conclude itself to be privy to the relationship between a doctrine in the standards and a particular passage of scripture? Careful there - you're thinking of the proof texts; the proof texts are just suggestive; we've never required a minister to believe *that* a particular proof text supports the doctrine that the authors of the confession believed it to support.
I'll try to make a future post clarifying what it is that the SJC needs to assert if even its claims, much less its conclusions, are to be understandable and not hopelessly ambiguous.
tidbits (RSS)
Had this awesome book as a kid: Kid's Whole Future Catalog » 02/04/2012
Alarming info about the cultural divide in the US from Charles Murray. » 01/25/2012
Loris has a really balanced approach to that guy with the religion/Jesus video. » 01/23/2012
Well written: To the Mother of Only One Child (the author has nine, and she isn't being snarky, I promise, it is an encouraging piece for mothers of all numbers of children) » 01/21/2012
interesting: how monogamy changed the world » 01/13/2012
Fascinating: the Chauvet Cave » 01/02/2012
I have a lot of mixed feelings about this article at Cardus. » 12/17/2011
Digital Humanities: Scanner sees more in ancient documents » 12/07/2011
Jakob Nielsen assesses the usability of the new Kindle Fire » 12/06/2011
Weezer covers Pumped Up Kicks » 12/02/2011
While there is no such thing as chafafa on the side, there really is shoo-fly pie and it is wonderful. » 12/02/2011
Cool: susan kare, the artist who created the early mac icons » 11/26/2011
wow: awesome plesiosaur fossil » 11/26/2011
Pepper spray on the scoville » 11/25/2011
These videos are hilarious: Bad Lip Reading / Herman Cain » 11/25/2011
Saw this new magazine at the Library: Autism. Kind of thin, but... » 11/24/2011
Muppet illustrations from a local St. Louis Artist: Muppabet » 11/23/2011
Design: saying goodbye to the old, traditional telephone » 11/23/2011
Concept: champerty » 11/19/2011
Cool: touchable holography » 11/09/2011
amazon wishlist
amazing people i know now
annie road to raeanna tifani d'arcy abby e. jennifer h. april p. jessie s. jandy s. joshua a. mark h. jeff m. bobber w. george e.people i know from childhood
alan c.news links
europac cnet news drudge report ny times wall st. journal frontline new madrid fault race in americaother blogs
the sartorialist built st. louis blane carrifex textism kyriosity lollardy sacra doctrina leithart hoguester amy loves books jeremy huggins ck rick and rachel witts gideon strauss 43 folders janely matt smith miner dawn eden the dane mmorgan folding a map flickr phil sintiere common grounds coudal josiah barb mystery + misery d kirk a crouch bledsoe b wilder pduggie alastair take joy muggle matters baird college girl huggins's photos writers read covenant worldwide design observer mcknight a bradley per caritatem babbler rustyfish sweet and sour banty rooster tolle blogge trinitarian lifeart
howard finster jerry brown m. f. robinson jeanne goodman dick blick anthony ross ron mueck pinhole photography stencils del carmen lartique flw house in STL klimt allergies hambone david bryce bryan cunningham chris jordan lensbabies galifianakis ann wood julian beever tobyweiss tom wegrzynowski cool stationeryscience
sanford real climate rtb vaccine awakeningmusic
beanland wilco jay farrar paul westerberg frank black the connells throwing muses liam lynch vanderslice peter adams christopher faiziweird things
death in the woodsgift ideas
raven maps Scharffenberger Chocolate Gourmet Coffee - Kuva Coffee Etsy (Handmade Goods) heath ceramics am sci and surplus leeners soorikian furniture inmod christian books and biblesmac stuff
marc liyanage sidenoteresearch tools
systran pocket mod ivr resource ADL STL Dev Corp greek bible nt greek audio jonathan edwards onlinechurches
providence church denver beal heights lodo movie cornerstone presbyterian church - St. Louis Missouri iscc saint andrew's, santa clarita CAbusiness items
negotiated construction project leads price improvement team Web Design St. Louisquotes i don't want to forget
"I have read in Plato and Cicero sayings that are wise and very beautiful; but I have never read in either of them: Come unto me all ye that labor and are heavy laden."
-Saint Augustine
"Basically, I'm not interested in doing research and I never have been ... I'm interested in understanding, which is quite a different thing. And often to understand something you have to work it out yourself because no one else has done it."
-David Blackwell